As I read the first part of Campano’s Immigrant Students and Literacy many things struck me.
The fact that both Gerald and Celso have Filipino Manongs yet lived vastly different lives because of the choices their father and grandfather made is quit mind-boggling. Gerald’s grandfather runs away from his culture, moves his family to the east coast, and assimilates to the American culture and life styles. In turn, Gerald knows very little of who he is and where his family came from. His grandfather came to the United States to build a better life for his family and wants no reminders of his life from the past. Because of the decisions his grandfather made Gerald is rich with knowledge, opportunity and a comfortable living situation.
Whereas Celso knew is ethnic background from early on. He is proud of it and works hard to support his family. However, living in California with many other immigrant families has been a more difficult life for him than Gerald. Navigating school, having huge responsibilities at home, not having the material things kids he goes to school with have, all pose many challenges for Celso to be a confident, successful citizen one day. Even though Celso was Gerald’s student and he gave him many opportunities to bring his culture and identity into the classroom it wasn’t enough. There were too many other mandates that Gerald needed to adhere to and that didn’t support Celso and his strengths.
It doesn’t seem fair that a family needs to hide who they are in order to have a good life in the United States. Things are different in the northeast than California—will the new core standards make our world feel more like California, Texas, and Florida or more like New York? Does having the same (core standards) really mean that it’s equal?
If only teachers could see Carmen’s strengths—she has so many. Maybe she could feel successful. Instead she’ll probably drop out before she reaches high school. The signs of how she is feeling about school and what it has to offer her (really very little) are starting to show. When you dismiss a child’s strengths, identity, it feels as if you don’t care, don’t respect that child. How could you be in the world of teaching if you don’t have the utmost respect for children? In situations of stories like Carmen’s where she had to miss several weeks of school to tend to her dying father because he had no insurance, how can you not only have more respect for Carmen, but how can you not put her on a pedestal? It is more than a cultural issue it’s a class issue too. Do teachers use the curriculum mandates as an excuse? In Jones’ book Girls, Social Class and Literacy she says we are a nation that hides. Are teaching hiding from poverty and making excuses?
I was really taken aback by your question "Does having the same (core standards) really mean that it's equal?" I think this is so important to analyze and think deeper about. It's basically saying what's good for one student/class/school/city/state is good for all and we know this is totally false. I wonder what impact these new common core standards will have as they are already infiltrating schools, being used to write new curriculum to package up and send off to teachers, and having tests created to hold our teachers and school accountable. It is my fear that these standards, although seemingly meant for good on some level may continue to perpetuate the idea that students need to be fixed by schools. Gerald Campano wrote "Children are though of as the locus of problems that have prescriptive solutions" (2007, p. 28). This is often the feel I get from teachers who work with children that do no necessarily fit into the norms they have set as norms. Through all this research and inquiry, I hope that I can somehow have an impact on the teachers that I work closely with so that there can be a shift in the way children are viewed.
ReplyDelete